From Self-Doubt to Self-Love: Bible Study Themes in ‘Identity Crisis’

Imagine a world where you could create the perfect version of yourself to take on life’s challenges – someone who isn’t afraid, who’s confident, brave, and bold. For shy science student Madison, this dream becomes a reality in Identity Crisis, a powerful new film premiering November 1st on UP Faith & Family.

Madison, struggling with imposter syndrome, self-doubt, and fear, invents a way to clone herself. Her “perfect” clone does everything she’s too scared to try: applying for jobs, making new friends, and facing her fears head-on. But what happens when Madison realizes that perfection isn’t about being flawless, but about embracing who she already is?

This movie beautifully explores how we often view ourselves through a distorted lens, focusing on our weaknesses rather than our strengths. Madison’s journey teaches us that we don’t need to change who we are to be good enough – we simply need to believe in ourselves. With themes of identity, self-acceptance, and courage, Identity Crisis is an uplifting story that reminds us of an important truth: we are already perfectly made in God’s image.

Dive Deeper with the Identity Crisis Bible Study Guide

To complement the movie, we have compiled a Bible study guide created by the talented Boylan sisters, the writers of Identity Crisis. This guide is designed to spark meaningful conversations and reflections within your youth group, small group, family, or church community. For more faith-affirming resources like these, visit the Boylan sisters’ website.

Conversation 1: Mirror Mirror

“God saw all he had made and it was good.” — Genesis 1:31A

“Though the Lord is exalted, he looks kindly on the lowly; though lofty, he sees them from afar.” — Psalm 138:6 

Movie Moment: Early in the film, Harper, Madison’s confident and outgoing roommate, waltzes into their dorm room dressed as the evil queen from a fairy tale. She grabs a mirror that Madison has invented and dramatically asks, “Mirror Mirror, who’s the fairest of them all?”

Discussion: Reflect on how we often compare ourselves to others and how embracing both our strengths and weaknesses can lead to self-acceptance.

Prayer: Ask God for help in overcoming self-comparison and embracing our unique qualities.

Conversation 2: I Wish I Was…

“Wait for the Lord, be strong and take heart and wait for the Lord” — Psalm 27:14 

Movie Moment: Once Madison figures out how to perfect the imperfection of the apple, she decides to try it on herself. She feverishly types the words ‘Confident + Assertive + Brave’ into her machine, believing that possessing these traits would make her life better.

Discussion: Discuss which trait you would like to embody more and how you can take steps to embrace it in your life.

Prayer: Seek God’s strength to overcome fear and take risks.

Conversation 3: Avoiding the Mirror

“They are more precious than gold, than much pure gold, they are sweeter than honey, then honey from the honeycomb.” — Psalm 19:10

Movie Moment: Henry, the librarian encourages Madison to put herself out there by asking a boy out & applying for a new job that aligns with her interests. Madison shrugs him off, rejects the encouragement, and re-pins the job advertisement to the bulletin board.

Discussion: Reflect on times when you have avoided taking risks and how embracing opportunities can lead to growth.

Prayer: Ask for courage to step out of your comfort zone and trust in God’s plan.

Conversation 4: Being Shy Isn’t a Bad Thing

“In peace, I will lie down and sleep, for you alone, Lord, make me dwell in safety.” — Psalm 4:8

Movie Moment: Madison is half present on a date with Trevor. She runs back and forth switching places with her clone. At one point Trevor encourages her to be herself and if that includes being shy, that’s OK. However, rather than leaning in, Madison has her clone finish out the date.

Discussion: Discuss how embracing traits we view as negative can actually be empowering.

Prayer: Pray for peace and confidence to be yourself.

Conversation 5: Hiding

“Will evil doers never learn— those who devour my people as men eat bread and do not call on the Lord. There they are, overwhelmed with dread, for God is present in the company of the righteous.” — Psalm 14:5

Movie Moment: Madison finally realizes she must accept the help of her clone and lean in to the swap. In order to keep up the charade, she must hide while the clone does life for her. It doesn’t take long for Madison to realize that hiding in the closet is not the solution to all of her problems that she was hoping for.

Discussion: Reflect on times when you have hidden parts of yourself and how stepping into the light can lead to authenticity.

Prayer: Ask for God’s help to reveal your true self and trust in His presence.

Conversation 6: I’m not perfect so how can I be enough?

“Lord, you also are my portion and my cup you make my lot secure.” — Psalm 16:5

Movie Moment: At the beginning of the film, Madison’s perfectionism prevents her from trying new things or sharing her ideas. Throughout the movie, she learns that perfection is not about being flawless but about being whole and complete. This realization helps her embrace her true self, including her strengths and weaknesses.

Discussion: Discuss how embracing imperfections can lead to a fuller life.

Prayer: Seek God’s strength to embrace your imperfections and trust in His perfection.

Conversation 7: Desperately Seeking Approval

“For you created my inmost being; you knit me together in my mother’s womb. I praise you because I am fearfully and wonderfully made; your works are wonderful, I know that full well.” — Psalm 139:13-14

Movie Moment: After singing at the Fall Festival, Madison’s clone asks her mother, “Are you proud of me now?” This question is left unanswered until later in the movie when Madison’s mother calls her before the winter formal and reassures her, “Madison, I have always been proud of you.” Even if your earthly mother has not told you she is proud of you, God sees, knows and loves you.

Discussion: Reflect on times when you have sought approval from others and how finding approval in God can provide a stronger sense of self.

Prayer: Pray for the ability to trust in God’s love and approval.

Join Us for the Premiere on November 1st!

Identity Crisis is more than a movie – it’s a reminder of God’s love and the power of self-belief. Mark your calendars for November 1st, grab some popcorn, and invite your friends and family for a night of inspiration, self-discovery, and encouragement. After the film, take a moment to reflect on Madison’s journey and dive into the Bible Study to unlock your own “perfect” identity – just the way God made you.

Ready to start your own journey of self-discovery? Stream Identity Crisis on UP Faith & Family and join us in celebrating the beauty of who you already are!