Based on the beloved book series, 'Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries' is a heartfelt mystery series set in a peaceful town where every case uncovers truth, restores relationships, and reveals the strength of community.

After a difficult breakup, Cheryl (Plus One at an Amish Wedding star Galadriel Stineman) arrives in Sugarcreek for a fresh start, taking over a local Amish gift shop. But when unexpected events, including unsettling discoveries and a sudden kidnapping, disrupt the town’s quiet rhythm, she’s drawn into a mystery that runs deeper than it first appears.

With locals Naomi (Denise Gossett) and Levi Miller (Galadriel's real-life husband, Kevin Joy) by her side, Cheryl begins to uncover hidden tensions and long-held secrets within the close-knit community. As each clue brings them closer to the truth, they also discover that healing, forgiveness, and faith play a powerful role in finding the way forward.