There’s a reason viewers keep coming back to Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries. Yes, each story delivers a cozy mystery to solve, but the real magic is found in the people: heartfelt friendships, second chances, family bonds, and a community where everyone looks out for one another. Whether you’ve been there from the beginning or discovering it for the first time, now is the perfect moment to meet the four characters at the center of it all!

🏙️ Cheryl Cooper: The Curious Outsider Who Finds Her Place

When Cheryl Cooper first arrives in Sugarcreek from Chicago, she’s carrying heartbreak from a broken engagement to her fiancé, Lance. A former bank employee in her 30s, Cheryl needs a fresh start, and finds one in Ohio, where she moves to help her Aunt Mitzi run the Swiss Miss Gift Shop, while she is away doing humanitarian work in New Guinea.

What begins as a temporary reset quickly turns into a whole new chapter: Cheryl’s sharp instincts, curiosity, fresh perspective, and love of true-crime podcasts make her an unexpected natural when mysteries begin popping up around town. Whether she’s noticing details others miss or asking questions no one else thinks to ask, Cheryl (with respected local Naomi by her side) has a way of finding herself right in the middle of every case.

Then, just when Cheryl begins settling into her new life, Lance reappears in the series (Episode 3, O Little Town of Sugarcreek). Their reunion brings unresolved feelings, new perspective, and even the chance to work together as they help solve a mystery.

As Season 1 unfolds, viewers will discover that Cheryl’s greatest journey isn’t solving cases, it’s learning that sometimes the ending you planned makes room for something even better.

🥧 Naomi Miller: The Wise Heart of Sugarcreek

Naomi Miller is the steady presence every town needs. Warm, welcoming, and deeply rooted in faith, Naomi offers wisdom, encouragement, and the occasional reality check when emotions run high. A talented baker and devoted mother, Naomi has spent her life caring for others, including Levi, who she took in when he was very young (along with his sister Sarah) and raised as one of her own. That nurturing spirit extends far beyond her family. When Cheryl arrives in Sugarcreek unsure of what comes next, Naomi quickly becomes one of her strongest supporters and closest friends, serving as her liaison to the Amish community.

Naomi also proves to be a surprisingly sharp sleuth. Her teamwork with Cheryl often uncovers clues and connections that unintentionally complicate Chief Twitchell’s official investigations, much to his frustration.

She may prefer a calm kitchen to a crime scene, but Naomi has a gift for understanding people, seeing the bigger picture, and helping everyone around her find their footing with warmth and wisdom.

⚒️ Levi Miller: The Good Guy Everyone Roots For

Levi Miller is hardworking, loyal, and the kind of person people can always count on. Quietly confident and deeply connected to the Sugarcreek community, Levi often lets his actions speak louder than words. Raised by Naomi after being taken in at a young age, Levi grew into a man shaped by kindness, gratitude, and a strong sense of responsibility. Skilled at building and fixing things with his hands, he’s always ready to help a neighbor, lend support, or step in when someone needs him most.

Levi also stands out in another way. By Amish standards, he is a little older to still be unmarried, which makes his story especially compelling. He’s steady, thoughtful, and has spent years putting responsibility before romance. His connection with Cheryl becomes one of the sweetest parts of the series. Their playful banter feels natural thanks to a shared sarcastic sense of humor, and what begins as teasing slowly grows into something deeper. As the season unfolds, viewers see a relationship built on trust, kindness, and genuine understanding. Their budding romance feels especially authentic because Levi and Cheryl are portrayed by real-life married couple Kevin Joy and Galadriel Stineman.

Esther Miller: Sweet, Smart, and Full of Heart

Esther Miller brings youthful charm and bright energy to Sugarcreek. Naomi’s daughter is thoughtful, observant, and often notices more than people realize. She loves books, enjoys the little joys of town life, and has a sweet romantic streak that makes her instantly endearing. Esther may be young, but she has a strong sense of self and isn’t afraid to speak up when it matters. As Cheryl becomes part of the community, Esther helps show her the warmth, humor, and heart that make Sugarcreek so special. She represents the next generation, grounded in tradition, but curious about the future, with sweetness and youthful spirit.

Fans will also love this behind-the-scenes connection: Esther is played by actress Riley Beeson, the real-life daughter of Denise Gossett (Naomi) making their on-screen mother-daughter bond feel even more special.

💡 Don’t Miss the Season Finale!

The clues come together, relationships deepen, and heartfelt moments await in the Season 1 finale of Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries on Thursday, June 4th, streaming only on UP Faith & Family. Start watching now to catch up on each case and meet the characters fans can’t stop talking about!