Sugarcreek Weekly Fan Hub

Welcome to the Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries Fan Hub, the go-to spot for fans who want to dive a little deeper into the world of the series. Check back each week so that you don’t miss a single cozy challenge or delicious recipe inspired by the latest episode.

Are you as obsessed as Cheryl? Start a conversation in the comments! Think you’ve noticed something peculiar like Naomi? Share your thoughts below and see what other fans are noticing. Then, check the top comment on this post for the correct answers to each week’s activity.

🥣 From the Sugarcreek Kitchen🍴

Esther’s Apple Butter Tart:

💡 Click for the full recipe!

Amish Celebration Cake:

💡 Click for the full recipe!

Naomi’s Honey Oat Cookies:

💡 Click for the full recipe!

Sweet Amish Friendship Bread:

💡 Click for the full recipe!

Yummy Amish Pot Pie:

💡 Click for the full recipe!

Delicious Strawberry Jam Recipe:

💡 Click for the full recipe!

Naomi’s Famous Apple Fritters Recipe:

💡 Click for the full recipe!

Which Sugarcreek Character Are You?

👀 Did You Catch That? 👀

From Episode 1: “The Buggy Before the Horse”  

💡 Click for the answers! 

If you need a refresher on what might have changed in the image, go back to watch the premiere.

Check back here next week for the correct answers.